That must have been it. Opened the ports you listed and I can see my server now! Thanks so much for all the help.
On a side, do you know the proper way to setup a map rotation? Also, how one would switch to Co-Op play? I remember back in the day my friends and I would all put ourselves on Germany and load up bots to try and take the beach from us on Normandy. I can't seem to figure it out on the server though (without shutting down and launching new).